Description:
Not Magic Enough.
For
Delae - a lonely landholder on the edge of the Kingdoms - a frantic
knock at the door on a stormy winter's night brings a cry for help.
After
centuries of war, Elves have little contact with the race of Men, but
Dorovan can't bring himself to ride past those so obviously in need. One
small act - with enormous consequences. Not Magic Enough is a tale of
love and honor, duty and determination.
Setting Boundaries
After
centuries of war an uneasy peace has finally been negotiated between
Elves, Dwarves and Men, thanks to Elon of Aerilann, Elven councilor to
the High King of Men. One final task yet remains, one final bone of
contention - to set the boundaries between their lands. It's a task that
will be easier said than done. Although most of the lesser Kings signed
the Alliance, not all wish to see it succeed and some are willing to
oppose it.
Violently.
For journeyman wizard Jareth it's the opportunity of a lifetime.
What he doesn't know is that the journey will test him to his limits and forge a friendship that would last for centuries.
Review 3 of 5 Stars
Not
Magic Enough and Setting Boundaries are novellas from Valerie Douglas'
Coming Storm series. Despite trying to be Tolkien-like they don't
really have much in common except that there are elves and humans in
both stories. So I'm going to give some overall comments and then take
them one at a time. Ms. Douglas definitely has the talent to turn a
phrase. The rhythm is good and they mostly flowed pretty well aside from
some repetitiveness; however, a little more proofreading couldn't
hurt. That being said, I was able overlook the mistakes more in the
first of the two than the second, but that was because of the quality of
the stories being told. Now on to the stories themselves.
Not
Magic Enough is a truly beautiful love story and of the two I definitely
enjoyed it the most. I'm a sucker for a good elf and lesser races love
story where the people are participating in a forbidden relationship. It
just adds to the intrigue. It's a fabulous daydream/fantasy and this
story was one that could have easily taken place somewhere in an
out-of-the-way holding. There is an overall sadness to the story being
told and in a lot of ways it's a story about settling for less than what
you can't have, but it's also a beautiful story of a truly loving
friendship between two people who know they are not for one another in
the long run. If I were reviewing these separately this story probably
would have received a 4 just for the story itself.
But since they
were bound together we move on to Setting Boundaries. Once again some of
the writing was truly lovely and some needed to be proofread again (and
that's exactly what I was thinking as I read this). However, this story
didn't have the depth that I'm looking for in something of its ilk. The
elves and a human wizard set off to set boundary stones to mark the
lands for the older and younger races and this is a story about their
journey. Mostly the journey is pretty uneventful and I was a bit let
down after the first one. There are a couple of points where there's
some action, but I got the feeling that this would have been a good
intermediary chapter between much more exciting chapters to break the
tension if there was an actual book involved. It was a story of
friendship and fighting against prejudice, but in my opinion not all
that gripping or memorable and thus the set of two novellas was brought
down to 3 because I would have given this one a 2 if I had read it on
its own.
In the end I thought Not Magic Enough was a good
standalone love story. Setting Boundaries I could take or leave. Another
problem here is that these are novellas and though these two are
bundled together for a pretty low price, the two I saw from later in the
series are just barely under $5. I don't know about you, but I'm not
interested in buying a ton of novellas at $5 each, which really just
seem like overly long chapters to try to build a book myself. If the two
stories are related aside from being on the same world then there isn't
much to relate one to the other that I could tell aside from the elder
races and the younger races being at odds. So there you have it. It was a
mixed bag for me. Though the romance of the first story was done very
well, I wasn't that impressed with the second one and won't be trying to
build this book one chapter at a time on my own by purchasing the later
novellas. If she truly finds the thread to join it all together it
might be a good book somewhere down the line, but I think I'll just wait
until then.
No comments:
Post a Comment
All comments will be reviewed. That does not mean negative comments will not be posted. I am just interested in weeding out spam and comments with what would be considered truly offensive language. If you can state your likes and dislikes with that in mind, the posts will not be removed.